Breaking News
More () »

Maine DOE, CDC stand firm as group of legislators calls for eased restrictions on reopening schools full-time

Maine Education commissioner Pender Makin says the Maine CDC hasn't seen any studies that say it's safe to have spacing lower than three feet of distance

AUGUSTA, Maine — A group of 51 Maine legislators sent a letter to the Maine Department of Education and Maine Center for Disease Control and Prevention calling for the immediate easing of restrictions that are preventing schools from reopening full-time.

School districts across the state that are operating under a hybrid model are often doing so with three feet of spacing between students, and six feet of spacing between students and adults. This guidance comes from both the U.S. CDC and Maine CDC.

Rep. Nathan Carlow (R-Buxton) initiated the letter, which includes signatures from Senators and Representatives from both political parties.

“Schools across Maine have reported minimal transmission of coronavirus,” Rep. Carlow said in a release. “In light of that and other factors, continued restrictions preventing schools from reopening full-time are excessive. This letter is designed to get the DOE and CDC to act for the good of students, parents, teachers and Maine.”

While the legislators argue in the letter that "numerous studies from multiple states similar to Maine in terms of population and population density have suggested that the consequences of reopening schools have been exaggerated," Maine DOE commissioner Pender Makin tells NEWS CENTER Maine that the Maine CDC hasn't seen data that supports having kids spaced out any less than three feet apart.

"They [Maine CDC] haven't seen any studies that say it's safe to have spacing lower than the three feet of distance. Until that happens I don't think we're going to be able to change that and that is the actual critical piece," Makin said.

Makin added that there are a lot of factors taken into account when it comes to distancing in schools.

"It can be the size of the building, it can be the layout, the way the buildings,  the way the classrooms are structured," she said.

The MSAD6 school board has also voted in favor of a resolution, urging the governor, the Maine DOE, and the Maine CDC to immediately review and revise the framework for reopening schools and returning to in-person instruction.

"The board is obviously concerned about the welfare of our teachers and staff as well as our students. This resolution is about maintaining local control, while of course continuing to maintain appropriate health safety measures to mitigate the spread of the virus," said at-large board member, Julie Anderson.

The DOE released the following statement:

Maine’s school guidance is aligned with Federal guidance, which includes measures such as mask wearing and a minimum of 3 feet of distance between students.

Elected officials should direct their concerns to the U.S. CDC for its public health experts to consider as they continue to take into account the latest science on keeping school communities safe.

The full letter from the legislators, addressed to Makin and Maine CDC Director Dr. Nirav Shah, reads as follows:

Dear Commissioner Makin and Director Shah:

We, the undersigned legislators, write to request that the Maine Department of Education (“DOE”) and Center for Disease Control and Prevention (“CDC”) work in conjunction to immediately ease the restrictions that are preventing schools from opening full-time.

We understand that current DOE and CDC guidance is that schools in “green” counties may open as long as they maintain physical distancing requirements, however, many school districts simply do not possess the capacity to bring all their students back to the classroom within this framework. The students in these districts are being denied access to a suitable education because of their school’s capacity limitations. In order to effectively and expeditiously facilitate the return of all students to the classroom, we advise that your departments rescind the 3-feet physical distancing requirement for students and that they direct school districts to implement a localized strategy for returning students back to a synchronous learning model; this is where young people learn best and can readily access school resources such as academic, counseling, and nutritional services.

Numerous studies from multiple states similar to Maine in terms of population and population density have suggested that the consequences of reopening schools have been exaggerated, and the continued restrictions placed on school districts have come at great cost to student mental and physical health. As school faculty and staff are beginning to receive the COVID-19 vaccination, school districts across Maine deserve flexibility to determine how best to return their students to school.

Schools across Maine have reported minimal transmission of the coronavirus; therefore, the continued justification of the aforementioned restrictions is excessive, and its practical implications are deeply troubling. The urgency with which we urge you to consider this request cannot be understated. The time is now and the need is clear.

Thank you for your prompt consideration of our concerns, and we look forward to hearing your responses.


Nathan Carlow
State Representative

/s/ Jeffrey Timberlake
Jeffrey Timberlake
Senate Republican Leader

/s/ Kathleen Dillingham

Kathleen Dillingham
House Republican Leader

/s/ Rick Bennett
Rick Bennett
State Senator

/s/ Russell Black
Russell Black
State Senator

/s/ Bill Diamond
Bill Diamond
State Senator

/s/ Jim Dill
Jim Dill
State Senator

/s/ Brad Farrin
Brad Farrin
State Senator

/s/ Lisa Keim
Lisa Keim
State Senator

/s/ Chloe Maxmin
Chloe Maxmin
State Senator

/s/ David Miramant
David Miramant
State Senator

/s/ Marianne Moore
Marianne Moore
State Senator

/s/ Matt Pouliot
Matt Pouliot
State Senator

Trey Stewart
State Senator

/s/ Sue Austin

Sue Austin
State Representative

/s/ Sue Bernard
Sue Bernard
State Representative

/s/ Mark Blier
Mark Blier
State Representative

/s/ Meldon Carmichael
Meldon Carmichael
State Representative

/s/ Amanda Collamore
Amanda Collamore
State Representative

/s/ Jon Connor
Jon Connor
State Representative

/s/ Patrick Corey
Patrick Corey
State Representative

/s/ Josanne Dolloff
Josanne Dolloff
State Representative

/s/ Gary Drinkwater
Gary Drinkwater
State Representative

/s/ Jack Ducharme
Jack Ducharme
State Representative

/s/ Billy-Bob Faulkingham
Billy-Bob Faulkingham
State Representative

/s/ Justin Fecteau
Justin Fecteau
State Representative

/s/ Steven Foster
Steven Foster
State Representative

/s/ Randall Greenwood
Randall Greenwood
State Representative

/s/ Abigail Griffin
Abigail Griffin
State Representative

/s/ Chad Grignon
Chad Grignon
State Representative

/s/ Jeffrey Hanley
Jeffrey Hanley
State Representative

/s/ Allison Hepler
Allison Hepler
State Representative

/s/ Sherman Hutchins
Sherman Hutchins
State Representative

/s/ Michael Lemelin
Michael Lemelin
State Representative

/s/ Laurel Libby
Laurel Libby
State Representative

/s/ Sheila Lyman
Sheila Lyman
State Representative

/s/ Genevieve McDonald
Genevieve McDonald
State Representative

/s/ Joshua Morris
Joshua Morris
State Representative

/s/ Cathy Nadeau
Cathy Nadeau
State Representative

/s/ Daniel Newman
Daniel Newman
State Representative

/s/ Beth O’Connor
Beth O’Connor
State Representative

/s/ Jennifer Poirier
Jennifer Poirier
State Representative

/s/ Shelley Rudnicki
Shelley Rudnicki
State Representative

/s/ Heidi Sampson
Heidi Sampson
State Representative

/s/ Peggy Stanley
Peggy Stanley
State Representative

/s/ Paul Stearns
Paul Stearns
State Representative

/s/ Jim Thorne
Jim Thorne
State Representative

/s/ Will Tuell
Will Tuell
State Representative

/s/ Nathan Wadsworth
Nathan Wadsworth
State Representative

/s/ Dustin White
Dustin White
State Representative

 /s/ Lynne Williams
Lynne Williams 

State Representative