Breaking News
More () »

Maine's Leading Local News: Weather, Traffic, Sports and more | Maine | NewsCenterMaine.com

Carine Reeves found guilty for 2017 murder of Sally Shaw

Carine Reeves of New York has been found guilty of the murder of Sally Shaw. She was shot and her body was left on the side of a road in Cherryfield in 2017.

BANGOR, Maine — Following 4 hours of deliberation, the jury delivered a guilty verdict for Carine Reeves in the 2017 murder of Sally Shaw.

Closing arguments were held Monday morning.

Carine Reeves of New York was charged with murder after Sally Shaw's body was found shot and left on the side of a road in Washington County's Cherryfield in 2017. 

Officials determined Shaw had died of gunshot wounds to the head. Court documents indicate Reeves had been using Shaw to sell drugs for him. Shaw's sister had explained Sally and Reeves were in an unhealthy relationship.

In 2018, Quaneysha Greeley of Lewiston pleaded guilty to Shaw's murder after a plea deal and agreed to testify against Reeves.

Credit: NCM
Sally Shaw's family reacts to the guilty verdict in the Carine Reeves murder trial

Sally Shaw's family spoke with reporters outside of the Penobscot County Judicial Center in Bangor after the guilty verdict was given. 

Shaw's daughter Heather Senechiame said,  "Relief, that pressure on your chest for the last three years of wondering what it was gonna be like. It's relief, closure, a little bit of closure.

RELATED: Reeves murder trial begins in Bangor
RELATED: Woman charged with Cherryfield murder changes plea on other charges
RELATED: Cherryfield murder suspect set to make guilty plea

Reeves decided not to take the stand on the last day of the trial. He also tried to fire his defense counsel at one point during the trial, saying he felt they weren't doing what he had asked. 

During closing arguments, defense attorney Steven Smith tried to provide doubt, saying that Greeley had a motive to kill Shaw. 

"When you add up all the evidence, you have [Greeley's motive]," Smith told the court. "She is not a sister with Sally Shaw. She was Sally Shaw's rival in love or at least sex -- and she was Sally Shaw's successor. She wanted in on the action."

RELATED: First jury trial in Maine since the pandemic hit is set to begin in Bangor

Assistant attorney general Leanne Zainia responded, addressing the jury by saying, "Your verdict of 'not guilty' will tell Carine Reeves that he can’t hide anymore."

Reeves defense attorney – Stephen Smith said, "Obviously we're very disappointed. The jury was out for four hours. We really believe there was an alternate suspect here and Mr. Reeves very much wants to appeal."

Reeves's sentencing date has not yet been scheduled.

NEWS CENTER Maine will continue to update this story on-air and online. 

RELATED: Lawyer argues forcing "a Black man to wear a mask or to be judged by jurors wearing masks … is in our view unconstitutional.”