The state was previously ranked 18th overall in 2017.
In order of listing, the top five states in U.S. News' 2019 overall rankings are Washington state, New Hampshire, Minnesota, Utah and Vermont.
Massachusetts, Connecticut and Rhode Island – ranked 8th, 21st and 26th, respectively – rounded out the other New England states.
Crime & Corrections, the category in which Maine has performed best the last two years, having ranked first in 2018 and runner-up in 2017, remained top-three. Neighbors New Hampshire and Vermont were one and two.
Maine's worst category, Infrastructure, was one position higher than last year, yet stood as its weakest pillar for a consecutive year at 42nd among all U.S. states. Only Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, Mississippi, Connecticut, Arkansas, Louisiana, Rhode Island and West Virginia fared lower.
Education (28th), Fiscal Stability (28th) and Opportunity (27th) all ranked mid-level. Education was down nine spots, returning to its 2017 ranking, while Fiscal Stability and Opportunity were up and down one position, respectively.
At No. 3, Opportunity was Maine's second-best category in 2017.
Maine's second weakest category, Economy, is the same as last year at No. 37, maintaining a five-spot improvement from 2017.
Health Care (32nd) is half the rank it was in 2017, No. 18, and 10 spots down from last year's 22nd position.
Maine got No. 39 in Natural Environment, a new measure to the 2019 ranks that looks at air and water qualities, as well as pollution and toxin exposure.
Quality of Life, to which Maine ranked 12th in 2018, was dropped.
U.S. News' overall scores are based on different weights among the eight main categories, comprised of more than 60 subcategories.
Health Care and Education are each 16% of the score, Economy is 14%, Infrastructure and Opportunity are each 13%, Fiscal Stability is 11%, Crime & Corrections is 10% and Natural Environment is 8%.